ST*Rfish home
Children on the beach
ST*Rfish home
Social Studies Teachers' Notes
Teachers' Notes
Introduction
Learning Outcomes
Activity G Info
Activity 2M - criteria
Level 2 Assessments
Assessment A
Assessment B
Assessment C
Assessment D
Assessment E
Students' Activities
Fact Sheets
Resources
Cartoons
Game
Glossary
Downloads
Fish!


Assessment D: understanding social studies ideas by interpreting pictures and information

Resources
Traditional Maori fisheries
Maori fisheries today
Pacific Islands fishing traditions
Fishing methods
"Talking heads" cartoon set
"Resource conflict" cartoon
"Polluted beach" cartoon
Aim
To assess your ability to understand and illustrate ideas about how human behaviour affects New Zealand's fisheries resources.
Tasks
1 Describe the importance of fish for two different cultures. Say why it is important to them.
2 List two changes that have occurred in fishing because of increased technology. How have these changes affected the fishing industry and fisheries resources?
3 List two ways people are polluting the sea. What effect does pollution have on fish?
4 Why are Treaty of Waitangi issues important for fisheries management? How do you think the Government should deal with treaty issues regarding fisheries resources?
5 How can fisheries resources best be managed, so there are plenty left for future generations? Write about 20 lines and give reasons for your answer.
Top of page top
Assessment D: criteria and marking
Assessment criteria
Level 1: Identifies an idea about human behaviour.

Level 2: Attempts to demonstrate an understanding of an idea about human behaviour.
Level 3: Demonstrates some understanding of an idea or ideas about human behaviour.
Level 4: Demonstrates an understanding of an idea about human behaviour.
Level 5: Demonstrates a thorough understanding of an idea about human behaviour.
Marking schedule
This assessment needs to be marked flexibly as a student may get a question wrong, but in answering other questions demonstrate an understanding of the issues. As a general guideline:
Level 1: Names two different cultures, gives one example of technological change (bigger boats, better navigational equipment, better fish finding equipment, able to process fish on board while at sea, etc), and one way people pollute the sea.
Level 2: Can name two cultures and say why fish are important to them (eg, diet, spiritual, historical). Can give two examples of technological changes and two ways people pollute the sea. Attempts to explain the effects of technology on the fishing industry and fisheries resources. (Fishing is now big business. Can catch more fish more efficiently. The ability to catch more fish has lead to overfishing in some areas.) Attempts to explain how pollution can affect fish (eg, affects their reproduction and growth).
Level 3: Demonstrates an understanding of the effect of technology or pollution. Recognises that Treaty of Waitangi issues are important.
Level 4: Recognises that Treaty of Waitangi issues are important and gives a partial explanation of their importance. (Examples of Treaty issues are the importance of treaties, the expectations of the tangata whenua, European settlers and British Government at the time the Treaty was signed, and current issues arising out of the treaty such as the Government giving some quota to Maori iwi through the Treaty of Waitangi Fisheries Commission.)

NB: Treaty issues delayed the development of the Quota Management System to cover further species. However, these constraints were removed with the passing of the Treaty of Waitangi (Fisheries Claims) Settlement Act in late 1992, and the later Fisheries Act 1996.
Level 5: Is able to suggest at least three ways of conserving fisheries resources or gives one suggestion, but gives a full explanation of that suggestion. (Students could talk about the Quota Management System and other regulations covering commercial fishing, regulations for amateur fishing, taiapure, giving quota to Maori, etc).

 

Introduction | Learning Outcomes | Activity G info | Activity 2M criteria
| Assessment A |
Assessment B | Assessment C | Assessment D | Assessment E
Top of page top
Back Next